Philip O'Carroll's Letters to The Editor

email: phil3068@hotmail.com     fax: (03) 9482 3226     Home

Fair Sharing

       Thursday, August 30, 2001

When one or two people want to share something I have, I might be willing.  But if I see many converging on me, I put away what I have and keep it to myself.

Perhaps this is what is happening with our refugee situation today.  We Australians have welcomed millions of newcomers over the years  —  especially when we have invited them.  But when faced with a queue swelling out of control, we naturally feel inclined to slam the doors. 

The obvious answer lies in a fair setting of limits. There is as yet no global umpire for migration.  But social geographers could draw up a list of how many each country would humanely take on the basis of resources and needs. 

This would not be a law but it would give us a guideline as to how many we should admit  —  and at the same time reassure us that we are not being exploited.

Philip O'Carroll